INTERVIEW · NEGOTIATION · 2025

The Psychology of the Business Seller

Jonathan Jay and influence expert Andy Harrington reveal what really motivates business sellers — and how to make your initial approach irresistible by asking the right questions and coming from a place of genuine empathy.

30 min 43 sec Jonathan Jay & Andy Harrington Influence & Negotiation

Seller Psychology

What really motivates sellers beyond money

The Right Questions

A framework for uncovering the truth

Closing the Deal

Building trust & booking that meeting

About This Interview

Most people think buying a business is all about the money — but it isn't. In this fascinating conversation, Jonathan Jay sits down with Andy Harrington, an expert in influence and selling, to explore what actually happens in the mind of a business seller when you pick up the phone.

Andy explains that the key to a successful acquisition call isn't talking — it's asking. The right questions help the seller reveal their true motivations, not just to you, but to themselves. When you can activate the problem in their neurology, they become far more motivated to act. This episode covers everything from building initial rapport, to dealing with a reluctant seller, to closing with a face-to-face meeting.

What You'll Discover

  • Why seller motivation goes far beyond money — and how understanding it is the key to tailoring your proposition
  • Why "selling is not telling" — and how asking the right questions gets sellers to reveal the truth about their situation
  • How to come from a place of genuine empathy and care — and why that approach works better than any sales technique
  • How to activate the seller's problem in their own neurology, making them more motivated to take action
  • The framework of questions to use on your initial discovery call — and how to build rapport that creates trust
  • How to handle reticence from a business owner who seems reluctant to open up
  • How to close the call by booking a face-to-face meeting — the critical next step in any acquisition
  • How to use the seller's pain points to craft a deal that genuinely satisfies both parties

About Andy Harrington

Andy Harrington is a world-renowned expert in influence, selling, and persuasion. He has trained thousands of entrepreneurs and business owners to communicate more effectively and close more deals by understanding human psychology.

Want to master the art of approaching business sellers?

Get Jonathan Jay's free business buying toolkit and start your acquisition journey